When exploring the world of options trading, it’s essential to understand key concepts like exercise value, time value, and moneyness. These elements influence an option holder’s decisions and the overall profitability of an option contract.

Through a simple agreement between two parties, Andy and Brooks, we’ll walk through how these concepts come into play—examining the factors that determine whether exercising an option makes financial sense. This foundation will also help set the stage for a deeper discussion about different styles, including European vs American options, and why timing and market conditions are critical to options strategies.

Understanding Options: Setting Up the Agreement

Suppose Andy and Brooks agree that in 30 days, Andy can purchase a ring from Brooks for $40. The spot price of the ring today is $35. Andy must also pay a $10 premium at initiation as part of the contractual agreement.

Decision at Expiration

A month has passed, and the contract is about to expire. Will Andy exercise his option? It depends. Andy holds the right (not obligation) to complete the transaction. As the long party, he’ll compare the agreed-upon purchase price to the current market price. His decision to exercise the option hinges entirely on whether it is financially beneficial.

Market Price and Option Execution

Let’s assume the ring’s market price at expiration is $45. Since $45 (market price) is greater than $40 (strike price), it’s profitable for Andy to exercise the option. He can buy the ring for $40 and immediately sell it for $45, making a $5 gain. If the market price had been less than $40, Andy would’ve opted out of the option and bought the ring at the cheaper market rate.

Strike Price and Exercise Value

The strike price (also called the exercise price or option price) is the agreed-upon price at which Andy can buy the ring—in this case, $40.The exercise value measures the benefit of exercising the option at expiration. It’s calculated as:

Exercise Value = Market Price – Strike Price

Andy will only exercise if doing so yields a positive benefit. In our example—with a market price of $45 and a strike price of $40—the exercise value is $5. If the market price were lower than the strike price, the exercise value would be zero—since Andy would not exercise the option.

Importantly, exercise value can never be negative—the option holder chooses not to exercise.

What About the Premium?

The $10 upfront premium is a sunk cost. Once spent, it cannot be recovered and does not influence the decision to exercise. Whether or not Andy profits from the option, the premium is already gone.

The Importance of Time

You may have noticed that timing is crucial when dealing with options. Why is duration so important? The answer lies in the time value of money. In the context of European vs Americanoptions, understanding how duration affects your strategy is key. Longer-duration options can provide a greater opportunity for favorable price movements—especially for call options like Andy’s, where the underlying asset’s price is expected to rise over time.

Understanding Moneyness

“Moneyness” refers to the relationship between the strike price and the market price:

  • In the Money (ITM): The market price is higher than the strike price. (Andy’s case: $45 > $40.)
  • At the Money (ATM): Market price equals the strike price.
  • Out of the Money (OTM): The market price is lower than the strike price.

Options in the money have a positive exercise value, while at-the-money and out-of-the-money options have an exercise value of zero.

European vs American Options

Now that we’ve seen how Andy’s option worked, we must understand that not all options can be exercised similarly. In addition to the basic structure of an option contract—giving the holder the right (not the obligation) to buy or sell an asset at the strike price—the exercise timing makes a big difference. This brings us to a crucial distinction between European vs American options.

In general, options are split into two types based on what they allow the holder to do:

  • Call options provide the right to buy an asset.
  • Put options give the right to sell an asset.

But the key difference between European vs American options lies in when they can be exercised. European options can only be exercised at the expiration date. American options can be exercised at any time before or at expiration.

Note that the terms “European” and “American” are naming conventions, not references to geographic markets.

There’s also a small difference in how we represent them in formulas:

  • European options: lowercase c (call) and p (put)
  • American options: uppercase C (call) and P (put)

Let’s look at a simple example to clarify. Suppose John, a retail investor, buys a July European call option on Apple shares with a $30 strike price. The premium costs $3. Apple’s market price is $75 at the expiration date. Because this is a European call, John can only exercise it at expiration—not before. He buys Apple stock at $30, gaining a $45 profit per share.

Notice that even if Apple’s stock price fluctuated wildly during the option’s life, John could not lock in profits early. For European options, only the price at expiration matters.

When the Values of European vs American Options Differ

Building on what we’ve discussed about European vs American options, it’s essential to understand that their values often differ because of the flexibility they offer. Since American options can be exercised before expiration, they provide more freedom to the holder than a similar European option, which can only be exercised at maturity. Because of this additional flexibility, the value of an American option is always at least equal to—and often higher than—the value of its European counterpart.

Let’s break it down a little further.

For American put options, the ability to exercise early is particularly valuable. If the underlying asset’s price drops sharply—possibly even to zero—the holder may want to sell immediately to maximize the benefit. This early exercise feature, unavailable to European puts, makes American puts more valuable.

The story is different regarding call options. If no cash flows (like dividends or interest) are expected during the option’s life, there’s generally no incentive for an American call holder to exercise early. In that case, European and American call options typically have the same value.

But if dividends or other cash flows are expected during the option’s life, an American call holder might choose to exercise early to claim those payments. The American call becomes more valuable than its European equivalent in such cases. In short, because European options can only be exercised at expiration and American options at any time, the general rule states:

The value of a European option is less than or equal to the value of an American option.

Foundations of Valuation and European vs American Options

This wraps up the foundational concepts of option valuation and derivative pricing—a crucial stepping stone for deeper exploration into options trading. Understanding the structure and mechanics of options, the differences between European and American contracts, and the factors that affect their value provides a solid base for anyone looking to navigate more advanced strategies. With these core principles in mind, you’ll be better equipped to assess risk, recognize profitable opportunities, and deepen your expertise as you move further into the dynamic landscape of derivatives.

To continue building your skills with expert-led courses and practical resources, we invite you to join the 365 Financial Analyst platform and take your financial education to the next level.

FREE SIGN UP